Rich-Poor gap gets deeper in America
3/7/18
The United Nations special rapporteur on
extreme poverty and human rights has blasted the growing income inequality
between the wealthy and poor in the United States, insisting in a new report
that the world’s richest country “is now moving full steam ahead to make itself
even more unequal.”
"The United States, one of the
world's richest nations and the "land of opportunity," is fast
becoming a champion of inequality," the report concluded. Americans born
into poverty are more likely than ever before to stay that way, according to a
United Nations report on poverty and inequality in the US.
Surely no one in the United States today
is as poor as a poor person in Ethiopia or Nepal? As it happens, making such
comparisons has recently become much easier. The World Bank decided in October
to include high-income countries in its global estimates of people living in
poverty. We can now make direct comparisons between the United States and poor
countries.
Properly interpreted, the numbers
suggest that the United Nations has a point — and the United States has an
urgent problem. They also suggest that we might rethink how we assist the poor
through our own giving.
According to the World Bank, 769 million
people lived on less than $1.90 a day in 2013; they are the world’s very
poorest. Of these, 3.2 million live in the United States, and 3.3 million in
other high-income countries (most in Italy, Japan and Spain).
The Trump
administration has slammed the UN report, arguing the organization should
instead focus on poverty in the third world.
US Ambassador to the UN Nikki Haley
said, "It is patently ridiculous for the United Nations to examine poverty
in America."
The report, presented Thursday in
Geneva, comes two days after Haley announced the US would withdraw from the UN
Human Rights Council.
Haley's comment was in response to a
letter from Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders and 18 other politicians calling on the
US to "take action to reduce shameful levels of poverty across the
country."
They agreed with the report's conclusion
that the Trump administration's $1.5 trillion in tax cuts "overwhelmingly
benefited the wealthy and worsened inequality."
Philip Alston, a New York University law
and human rights professor, led a UN study traveling across US. The group went
to Puerto Rico and Washington, D.C. Alabama, California, Georgia, West Virginia
were among the states they visited.
"Most Americans don't care about
it. They have bought the line peddled by conservative groups that poor people deserve
what they are getting," Alston, the UN special rapporteur on extreme
poverty and human rights, told CNN.
The report notes that the US has highest
child mortality rate of 20 rich countries (OPEC comparison). It also has among
the highest child poverty rates in the developed world, at 21%. It also
considered obesity rates, income inequality and incarceration rates.
Haley said the UN special rapporteur had
"categorically misstated" the progress America had made reducing
poverty, but she gave no examples.
Who are America's working poor?
More than 40 million Americans live in
poverty, according to the US census.
Maudine Fall has spent her life working
minimum wage jobs. At 56 years old, she became homeless. Although she continues
cleaning and catering, she rarely gets more than 30 hours of work a week.
Occasionally, she stays in shelters,
some nights she sleeps on the street. The worst part she says; you can never
let your guard down.
"I worry about the danger, you put
yourself in a vulnerable position when you're out here," she says.
Fall says it's
impossible to save money for a rental deposit.
"You're never able to save, you're
never able to really just build up and have a big deposit to put down. You're
struggling, day by day. Even working," she says.
If you are among the working poor living
pay check to pay check, one illness or natural disaster can put you on the
street.
John Bobbit is one such man.
He used to own a maintenance business
employing four people.
That all changed after Hurricane Katrina
slammed into New Orleans in 2005. He lost everything and ended up homeless for
almost a decade.
"Pride was my
biggest sin because I wouldn't ask people to help me. I always thought, 'I'm on my own, I've got to do this on my own.' I
turned to drugs and alcohol just out of self-pity, and I ended up digging
myself into a deeper hole," Bobbit said.
He was at rock bottom when he decided to
walk some 500 miles (more than 700kms) from New Orleans to Atlanta to start
anew. It took him 32 days.
Safehouse Outreach in downtown Atlanta
helped him find work in a major hotel.
"I was in a job program and they
started me off at $8.50. It's the most humble I've ever been in my life and I'm
50 years old. I'm used to making $25-30 an hour when I ran my own
business."
He was quickly promoted to a manager
position but was out of work 18 months later when illness struck.
Respiratory failure, cellulitis and gout
meant five weeks in hospital and many more weeks recovering. The hotel could
not hold his position.
Bobbit returned to Safehouse Outreach
first as a volunteer and then he was hired as the kitchen manager.
Today he's making grilled cheese
sandwiches and soup for the hundreds of people who struggle to survive on
minimum wage.
"We do a free, hot healthy meal to
anybody who walks in the door. That's lunch and dinner. In a given year, we'll
see about 4,000 people," said Safehouse Outreach CEO Josh Bray.
The underemployed
The official unemployment rate might be
at record lows, but Safehouse Outreach says it's seeing an increase in the
number of underemployed.
Nolan English runs the outreach program.
"At least 40% of the people we
serve are working, they're holding down two to three jobs, have children, they
may be trying to land on someone's couch, some live in abandoned buildings, in
their cars, then they come here and they go on shift, they work," he said.
Demetrius Philips and his wife, Shamika
Harper, both are minimum wage workers who are homeless.
At 38 years, Philips
earns just $8 hour.
"You might work today, might not
tomorrow, which puts you in a bind because you're only making $40-50 maybe $60
a day. So pay for a hotel room and buy something to eat, you don't have any
more money."
Across the US, people working for tips
can often earn as little as $2.13 an hour and have to make up the rest in tips
to meet the federal minimum wage of $7.25 an hour.
"They're not livable wages, they're
little tokens they're throwing, they're crumbs from your table," English
said.
The Obama administration pushed to raise
the minimum wage from $7.25 to $10.10 an hour in 2014, but Republicans blocked
the bill despite overwhelming support for the measure.
What is absolute poverty?
More than 5 million Americans live in
third world conditions also known as "absolute poverty," according to
the report.
In Lowndes County, Alabama, the report
found residents lacked basic sewage systems. Unable to afford a septic tank
some people constructed their own homemade sewerage lines using PVC piping.
The UN study also found 19 out of 55
people tested in Alabama had hookworm. It's a disease typically found in
developing countries, one that was thought to have been eradicated in the US in
the 1980s.
While the issue is not new, the problem
is becoming more dire under the Trump administration according to the UN.
It found Trump's policies seem
"deliberately designed to remove the basic protections from the poorest,
punish those who are not in employment and make even basic health care into a
privilege to be earned rather than a right of citizenship."
"Contempt for the poor in US drives
cruel policies," Alston, the UN Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and
human rights, told CNN.
"The Trump administration has
brought in massive tax breaks for corporations and the very wealthy, while
orchestrating a systematic assault on the welfare system," he said.
"The strategy seems to be tailor-made to maximize inequality and to plunge
millions of working Americans, and those unable to work, into penury.
Forty-six million Americans depend on
food banks, which is 30% above 2007 levels, according to Feeding
America.
"Even people who are working full
time can't afford a decent living. They do need food stamps. They do need the sort of assistance that
government can provide, but instead what we see is a constant cut back in all
of those benefits by this administration," Alston said./.
All comments [ 6 ]
On January 24, 2018, Nobel Prize–winning economist Angus Deaton published an op-ed in The New York Times entitled “The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem.”
In other analyses, the term “deep poverty” typically means a household with an income that is less than half of the official U.S. poverty income thresholds.
There are 5.3 million Americans who are absolutely poor by global standards.
It is hard to imagine poverty that is worse than this, anywhere in the world. Indeed, it is precisely the cost and difficulty of housing that makes for so much misery for so many Americans, and it is precisely these costs that are missed in the World Bank’s global counts.
Even for the whole population, life expectancy in the United States is lower than we would expect given its national income, and there are places — the Mississippi Delta and much of Appalachia — where life expectancy is lower than in Bangladesh and Vietnam.
How this make America human rights defender!
Your comments